Pesticide Kills

 

Numerous dead bees in front of hive.
Dead bees within the hive.

Pesticides are substances used to eliminate unwanted pests. Insecticides rid us of unwanted insects. Unfortunately, honey bees are insects and are greatly affected by insecticides. There are several ways honey bees can be killed by insecticides. One is direct contact of the insecticide on the bee while it is foraging in the field. The bee immediately dies and does not return to the hive. In this case the queen, brood and nurse bees are not contaminated and the colony survives. The second more deadly way is when the bee comes in contact with an insecticide and transports it back to the colony, either as contaminated pollen or nectar or on the its body. The main symptom of honey bee pesticide kill is large numbers of dead bees in front of the hives. Another symptom is a sudden loss of the colony's field force. After a honey bee pesticide loss the colony may suffer additionally from brood diseases and chilled brood.

Many pesticides are extremely toxic to honey bees and other beneficial insects. Honey bees are attracted to blooming flowers of all types. If at all possible do not spray blooms directly with pesticides. If the bloom needs to be sprayed, apply the pesticides in the evening hours. Honey bees forage during daylight hours when the temperatures are above 55-60°F. As the sun begins to set, they return to their hives for the evening. Thus, spraying pesticides in the evening hours can greatly reduce honey bee mortality because the bees are not in the fields. Choosing the correct formulation is another way to avoid honey bee pesticide kills. Pesticides come in different formulations: dusts (D), wettable powders (WP), soluble powders (SP), emulsifiable concentrates (EC), solutions (LS), and granulars (G). Solutions, emulsifiable concentrates, and granulars are the best formulations to use. Solutions and emulsifiable concentrates dry quickly and do not leave a powdery residue behind unlike the dusts and wettable powders. Granulars are similar to dusts but are larger in particle size. They are applied into the soil or broadcast on the surface of the ground. They are seldom used on blooming plants and are essentially non-hazardous to bees. On the other hand dusts and wettable powders will adhere to the thousands of tiny hairs found on the body surface of the honey bee. These dust particles are then transferred back to the hive and stored along with the pollen. This can cause an entire colony to collapse if the pollen is fed to the queen or the brood. Using less toxic pesticides that degrade rapidly is also important in reducing honey bee mortality (See the table for pesticide toxicity and residual time). Many of the newer pesticides being marketed today have a faster residual time which is the time required to reduce the activity of the chemical to safer levels for bee activity. When these pesticides are sprayed in the fields, it takes only a few hours for them to degrade as opposed to a few days or weeks.

Finally, the method of application can also change the risk of pesticide poisoning. Aerial applications have the highest potential risk for causing bee kills. Most bee kills occur when the pesticide drifts or moves from the target area into the apiary or onto crops attractive to the bees. The outcome of drift can be catastrophic. Spraying during windy days greatly increases the risk of drift. Using granular formulations, soil treatments or equipment that confines the spray to the intended target, can help reduce the risk of drift from pesticides.

The location of your apiary is probably the most important factor in eliminating the risk of pesticide poisoning. The farther colonies are away from fields or orchards that are treated with pesticides, the better chance the bees have against pesticide poisoning. Establish apiaries at least 4 miles from crops being treated with toxic materials and subjected to drift. However, if your apiary is already located in an agricultural area where pesticide use is high, moving your bees may be the best insurance against future pesticide kills since preventing honey bees from foraging on pesticide-contaminated flowers is otherwise impossible. If moving is impossible, try covering colonies or using other methods to restrict honey bee flight during peak foraging hours. However, this method has dangerous side effects and could lead to higher mortality than would have occurred from pesticide exposure. Colonies may have difficulty controlling their hive temperature when confined and can easily overheat so care must be taken. Providing water inside the hive will allow the bees to reduce temperatures. Do not keep the colony covered for more than two days. Covering the colonies with large wet burlap sacks and providing them with shade is the best method for preventing overheating.

Colonies that have been exposed to pesticides can recover if proper steps are taken. If a colony has lost a majority of its field force but has plenty of honey and pollen it will usually recover without any help from the beekeeper. However, if brood and nurse bees die, the pesticide is present in the hive, probably in the pollen supplies. The colony will continue to die as long as the poison remains in the hive. In these cases the combs themselves must be cleaned or removed. Just adding packaged bees will not remedy the problem. Soak the combs in water for 24 hours. Then wash the pollen from the cells and allow the combs to dry. Another method is to remove the wax comb and replace it with new foundation. To help colonies recover from bee poisoning, feed the colonies sugar syrup, pollen, water, add a package of bees or combine weak colonies, protect from heat or cold and move them to a pesticide free area with nectar and pollen sources.

 

Table1 of common insecticides and miticides and their relative risk to honey bees. Never spray during bloom periods unless it is absolutely necessary. If treatment is unavoidable, choose a product with a high LD50 and short residual. If a more toxic chemical is required, choose a residual under 8 hours and spray at night.

Active Ingredient

Trade Names

Risk Class2

LD503

Residual4

acephate

Orthene

I

1.2

1 day to >3 days

aldicarb

Temik

I

0.35

>1 day to >2 days

azinphos methyl

Guthion

I

0.43

2 days to >5 days

Bacillus thuringiensis

Biobit, Cutlass, Dipel, Javelin, Thuricide

III

NA

<2 hours

carbaryl

Sevin

I

1.5 to 26.5

<2 hours to 12 days

chlorpyrifos

Dursban, Lorsban

I

0.11

5 hours to 6 days

cyhexatin

Plictran

III

NA

<2 hours

cypermethrin

Ammo, Cymbush

III

NA

<2 hours to >3 days

diazinon

Diazinon

I

0.37

<1 day to 2 days

dicofol

Kelthane

III

NA

<2 hours

dicrotophos

Bidrin

I

0.3

1 day to 1 days

diflubenzuron

Dimilin

III

NA

<2 hours to 6 hours

dimethoate

Cygon, De-fend, Rebelate

I

0.19

<2 hours to >3 days

disulfoton

Di-syston

II

6.12

<2 hours to 7 hours

endosulfan

Thiodan

II

7.8

<2 hours to 1 day

ethion

Ethion oil

III

NA

<2 hours

fluvalinate

Mavrik

III

65.8

<2 hours

fonofos

Dyfonate

II

8.68

<2 hours to 6 hours

formetanate hydrochloride

Carzol

II

9.2

<2 hours to 2 hours

lindane

Lindane

I

NA

>2 days

malathion

Cythion, Malathion

I

0.73

<2 hours to 5 days

methamidophos

Monitor

I

1.37

4 hours to 1 day

methidathion

Supracide

I

0.24

day to 3 days

methomyl

Lannate

I

1.29

<2 hours to >1 day

methoxychlor

Marlate, Methoxychlor

III

NA

<2 hours

methyl parathion

Penncap-M

I

0.11 to 0.24

<1 day to >7 days

mevinphos

Phosdrin

I

0.3

<2 hours to <5 hours

naled

Dibrom

I

0.49

2 hours to >1 day

oxamyl

Vydate

II

10.3

<2 hours to 12 hours

oxythioquniox

Morestan

III

NA

<2 hours

parathion

Parathion

I

0.18

10 hours to >1 day

permethrin

Ambush, Permethrin, Pounce

I

0.16

12 hours to >3 days

phorate

Thimet

II

10.25

<2 hours to 5 hours

phosmet

Imidan

I

1.13

8 hours to >3 days

profenofos

Curacron

II

3.46

<2 hours to 9 hours

propargite

Omite, Ornamite

III

NA

<2 hours

sulprofos

Bolstar

II

7.22

<2 hours to >1 day

thiodicarb

Larvin

II

7.08

<2 hours

trichlorfon

Dylox, Proxol

III

NA

<2 hours to 6 hours

1Table modified from Johansen & Mayer (1990) and Delaplane (1993).
2Risk classes: I = highly toxic to honey bees, II = moderately toxic to honey bees, III = relatively nontoxic to honey bees. The risk class is closely associated with the LD50.
3LD50 = the Lethal Dose required to kill 50% of the test honey bees, expressed in micrograms per bee. The smaller the LD50, the more toxic the product.
4Period of residual toxicity to honey bees after application. Evening applications of products with residuals of 8 hours or less generally cause only moderate harm to bees, even if the LD50 is small. For example, mevinphos is very toxic to bees, but because it has a short residual, it is fairly safe for early evening applications.

 

Honey Bee Disorders / UGA Honey Bee Program / UGA Entomology Department